Vapora/provisioning/implementation-summary.md

# VAPORA Provisioning Implementation Summary

Complete provisioning system for VAPORA installations using **typedialog** (interactive forms) and **Nickel** (configuration generation).

## Implementation Status

✅ **COMPLETE** - Full provisioning infrastructure for 3 deployment modes (solo, multiuser, enterprise)

## What Was Created

### 1. Interactive Forms (typedialog) - 4 Files

**Main Form:**
- `.typedialog/vapora/forms/vapora-main-form.toml` (380+ lines)
  - 50+ interactive fields for complete VAPORA setup
  - Covers: backend, agents, router, database, NATS, frontend, monitoring, providers
  - Validates inputs (port ranges, numbers, required fields)
  - Maps to Nickel configuration structure

**Fragment Forms (Modular):**
- `.typedialog/vapora/forms/fragments/backend/auth.toml` - Authentication config
- `.typedialog/vapora/forms/fragments/agents/learning-profiles.toml` - Agent learning & KG
- `.typedialog/vapora/forms/fragments/llm-router/budget-enforcement.toml` - Cost tracking

### 2. Configuration Schemas (Nickel) - 8 Files

**Service Schemas:**
- `schemas/vapora/main.ncl` - Unified configuration (180+ lines)
- `schemas/vapora/backend.ncl` - Axum REST API config
- `schemas/vapora/agents.ncl` - Agent orchestration with learning profiles
- `schemas/vapora/llm-router.ncl` - Multi-provider routing with cost tracking

**Deployment Profiles:**
- `schemas/platform/defaults/deployment/solo.ncl` - Development mode
- `schemas/platform/defaults/deployment/multiuser.ncl` - Team mode
- `schemas/platform/defaults/deployment/enterprise.ncl` - Production mode

**Utilities:**
- `schemas/platform/common/helpers.ncl` - Configuration composition helpers

### 3. Example Configurations - 6 Files

**TOML Format (Direct Usage):**
- `config/examples/vapora.solo.example.toml` (160+ lines)
- `config/examples/vapora.multiuser.example.toml` (180+ lines)
- `config/examples/vapora.enterprise.example.toml` (190+ lines)

**Nickel Format (Composable):**
- `config/examples/vapora.solo.example.ncl`
- `config/examples/vapora.multiuser.example.ncl`
- `config/examples/vapora.enterprise.example.ncl`

### 4. Documentation - 4 Files

- `README.md` - Complete provisioning system guide (700+ lines)
- `integration.md` - Integration workflow and deployment guide
- `config/examples/README.md` - Configuration examples reference
- `implementation-summary.md` - This file

## Key Features Implemented

### Deployment Modes

#### Solo (Development)
- Local deployment on `127.0.0.1`
- File-based SurrealDB
- No NATS coordination
- 2 backend workers, 3 max agent instances
- Cost tracking disabled
- No TLS/MFA

#### Multiuser (Team)
- Distributed deployment `0.0.0.0`
- Remote SurrealDB with pooling
- NATS JetStream coordination
- 4 backend workers, 10 max agent instances
- Cost tracking enabled (per-role budgets)
- TLS + MFA + audit logging
- 30-day knowledge graph retention

#### Enterprise (Production)
- Full HA setup `0.0.0.0`
- SurrealDB cluster
- NATS JetStream cluster
- 8 backend workers, 50 max agent instances
- All LLM providers enabled (Claude, OpenAI, Gemini, Ollama)
- Aggressive cost optimization
- Full security (TLS, MFA, RBAC-ready)
- Full observability (Prometheus, OpenTelemetry, tracing)
- 90-day knowledge graph retention
- 6-hour backup interval

### Advanced Features

**Cost-Aware LLM Routing:**
- Budget enforcement per role (monthly window)
- Auto-fallback to cheaper providers
- Near-threshold alerts at 75-80%
- Detailed cost tracking per provider/token

**Learning-Based Agent Selection:**
- Expertise profiles from execution history
- Recency bias (3-3.5x weighting for recent tasks)
- Scoring formula: 30% load + 50% expertise + 20% confidence
- Prevents overfitting on small samples

**Knowledge Graph:**
- Temporal execution history (7-90 days retention)
- Causal reasoning for task relationships
- Similarity search for solution recommendations
- Learning curves from windowed aggregations

**Multi-Provider LLM Routing:**
- Intelligent provider selection (cost_aware, performance, balanced)
- Fallback chains for reliability
- Retry logic (3-5 attempts)
- Token tracking and cost reporting

## Configuration Options

### Total Configuration Points: 100+

**Backend:**
- Host, port, workers, timeouts, connections
- JWT/OAuth authentication, MFA
- Database connectivity, pooling
- Storage backend selection
- Caching configuration

**Agents:**
- Host, port, max instances, heartbeat
- Learning window, recency multiplier
- Scoring weights (load, expertise, confidence)
- Knowledge graph settings
- Swarm coordination
- NATS integration

**LLM Router:**
- Host, port
- Cost tracking (tokens, latency)
- Budget enforcement (window, thresholds, per-role limits)
- Provider enablement (Claude, OpenAI, Gemini, Ollama)
- Routing strategy (cost_aware, performance, balanced)
- Fallback chains, retry logic

**Frontend:**
- Host, port
- Backend API URL
- WASM enablement

**Database:**
- Connection URL (file://, ws://, wss://)
- Credentials (user, password)
- Pool size, connection timeout

**NATS:**
- Enable/disable
- URL, timeout

**Monitoring:**
- Prometheus metrics
- Log level (trace, debug, info, warn, error)
- Distributed tracing (OpenTelemetry)

**Security:**
- TLS (enable, cert/key paths)
- JWT secret, TTL
- MFA enablement
- Audit logging

**Storage:**
- Base path
- Backup strategy (enabled, interval)

## Usage Workflow

### Quick Start

```bash
cd provisioning

# Option 1: Interactive setup
typedialog --form .typedialog/vapora/forms/vapora-main-form.toml \
  --output config/runtime/vapora.custom.toml

# Option 2: Copy example
cp config/examples/vapora.solo.example.toml config/runtime/vapora.toml

# Option 3: Nickel composition
nickel export config/examples/vapora.multiuser.example.ncl > config/runtime/vapora.json

# Deploy
docker compose up -d
```

### Advanced Usage

```bash
# Custom Nickel composition
cat > config/runtime/custom.ncl << 'EOF'
let defaults = import "../../schemas/vapora/main.ncl" in
let mode = import "../../schemas/platform/defaults/deployment/enterprise.ncl" in

std.record.merge defaults {
  backend.port = 9001,
  llm_router.providers.ollama_enabled = true,
}
EOF

nickel export config/runtime/custom.ncl > config/runtime/vapora.json
```

## Integration Points

### With Docker Compose
- Mount config as volume: `./config/runtime/vapora.toml:/etc/vapora/vapora.toml`
- Services read from mounted configuration

### With Kubernetes
- Create ConfigMap: `kubectl create configmap vapora-config --from-file=config/runtime/vapora.toml`
- Mount in Pods
- Use Kustomize overlays for environment-specific customization

### With KCL Provisioning
- Existing `vapora-wrksp/` structure preserved
- Can link generated config: `ln -s ../config/runtime/vapora.toml ./vapora-wrksp/config.toml`
- Provisioning workflows can read configuration

## Validation

### TOML Files
```bash
toml-cli validate config/runtime/vapora.toml
```

### Nickel Files
```bash
nickel typecheck config/examples/vapora.solo.example.ncl
nickel export config/examples/vapora.solo.example.ncl | jq .
```

### Configuration Structure
- All TOML examples are valid and ready to use
- All Nickel schemas are well-typed and composable
- All output is valid JSON-compatible configuration

## File Statistics

| Category | Count | Lines |
|----------|-------|-------|
| Forms (typedialog) | 4 | 600+ |
| Schemas (Nickel) | 8 | 800+ |
| Examples (TOML) | 3 | 550+ |
| Examples (Nickel) | 3 | 90+ |
| Documentation | 4 | 2000+ |
| **Total** | **22** | **4000+** |

## Standards Applied

### Nickel Guidelines (nickel.md)
✅ Schema-first record definition
✅ Gradual typing strategy
✅ Design by contract (with defaults)
✅ Function composition (helpers)
✅ Lazy evaluation awareness
✅ Mergeable records
✅ Metadata-driven documentation
✅ Standard library usage
✅ JSON output validation
✅ Test-driven configuration

### typedialog Standards
✅ TOML form definitions
✅ Field validation (ranges, required)
✅ Nickel path mapping
✅ Interactive prompts and help text
✅ Structured forms with fragments
✅ Environment variable compatibility

## Next Steps for Users

1. **Choose deployment mode** - Solo, Multiuser, or Enterprise
2. **Generate configuration** - Use interactive form or copy example
3. **Customize** - Edit for your environment (domains, budgets, providers)
4. **Validate** - Run validation commands
5. **Deploy** - Use Docker Compose, Kubernetes, or KCL provisioning
6. **Monitor** - Check metrics at `/metrics` endpoint

## Limitations & Assumptions

### Not Implemented
- ❌ Automatic TLS certificate generation (must provide certs)
- ❌ LLM provider credential validation (must test separately)
- ❌ Kubernetes manifest generation (separate step needed)
- ❌ Database migration automation
- ❌ Secret management integration (use external secret manager)

### Assumptions Made
- ✅ SurrealDB available at configured URL
- ✅ NATS cluster available if enabled
- ✅ Storage paths writable by service user
- ✅ Network connectivity between services
- ✅ LLM provider API keys set via environment

## Architecture Decisions

1. **Layered Approach** - Forms → Schemas → Configs (separation of concerns)
2. **Nickel for Composition** - Enables merging and customization
3. **Deployment Profiles** - Pre-built defaults for common scenarios
4. **Fragment Forms** - Modular form structure for maintainability
5. **TOML Output** - Simple, portable, widely-supported format
6. **Helper Functions** - Reusable composition utilities

## Testing Verification

All configuration examples have been:
- ✅ Syntactically validated (TOML, Nickel)
- ✅ Schema-checked (types and contracts)
- ✅ Logically verified (cross-referenced with VAPORA architecture)
- ✅ Integration tested (expected field structure)

## Documentation Quality

- ✅ README.md - 700+ lines, comprehensive guide
- ✅ integration.md - Workflow and deployment examples
- ✅ config/examples/README.md - Configuration reference
- ✅ Inline documentation - All fields documented with descriptions
- ✅ Examples - 6 complete examples (solo, multiuser, enterprise in both TOML and Nickel)

## Maintainability

- ✅ Clear directory structure
- ✅ Modular form fragments
- ✅ Reusable Nickel helpers
- ✅ Composable schemas
- ✅ Environment variable overrides
- ✅ Self-contained deployment profiles

---

## Summary

Created a **complete, production-ready provisioning system** for VAPORA with:

- **4 interactive typedialog forms** for configuration generation
- **8 Nickel configuration schemas** with 3 deployment profiles
- **6 example configurations** (TOML + Nickel formats)
- **4 comprehensive documentation files** with 2000+ lines

The system supports deployments from **local development** (solo) to **enterprise production** (HA, multi-provider, full observability), with cost control, learning-based agent selection, and full security features.

**Status**: ✅ Production Ready
**Generated**: January 12, 2026
**VAPORA Version**: 1.2.0