let d = import "../ontology/defaults/core.ncl" in { nodes = [ # ── Axioms (invariant = true) ───────────────────────────────────────────── d.make_node { id = "protocol-not-runtime", name = "Protocol, Not Runtime", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Axiom, description = "Onref is a protocol specification and tooling layer. It is never a runtime dependency. Projects implement the protocol; onref provides the schemas and modules to do so.", invariant = true, }, d.make_node { id = "self-describing", name = "Self-Describing", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Axiom, description = "Onref describes itself using its own protocol. The .ontology/, adrs/, and reflection/ directories in this repository are onref consuming ontoref.", invariant = true, artifact_paths = [".ontology/core.ncl", ".ontology/state.ncl", "adrs/"], }, d.make_node { id = "no-enforcement", name = "No Enforcement", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Axiom, description = "Onref defines contracts and patterns. There is no enforcement mechanism. Coherence is voluntary and emerges from justified adoption.", invariant = true, }, d.make_node { id = "dag-formalized", name = "DAG-Formalized Knowledge", pole = 'Yin, level = 'Axiom, description = "All project knowledge — concepts, tensions, decisions, state — is formalized as directed acyclic graphs. This enables transversal queries, impact analysis, and ecosystem-level visibility.", invariant = true, artifact_paths = ["ontology/schemas/", "crates/ontoref-ontology/"], }, # ── Tensions ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── d.make_node { id = "formalization-vs-adoption", name = "Formalization vs Adoption Friction", pole = 'Spiral, level = 'Tension, description = "Richer formalization produces better ecosystem visibility but increases the cost of adoption. The balance: schemas are optional layers, not mandatory gates.", }, d.make_node { id = "ontology-vs-reflection", name = "Ontology vs Reflection", pole = 'Spiral, level = 'Tension, description = "Ontology captures what IS (invariants, structure, being). Reflection captures what BECOMES (operations, drift, memory). Both must coexist without one dominating. This tension is onref's core identity.", }, # ── Practices ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── d.make_node { id = "adr-lifecycle", name = "ADR Lifecycle", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Architectural decisions follow: Proposed → Accepted → Superseded. Superseded ADRs retain constraints for historical reconstruction. Active Hard constraints drive the constraint set.", artifact_paths = [ "adrs/schema.ncl", "adrs/reflection.ncl", "adrs/_template.ncl", "adrs/adr-001-protocol-as-standalone-project.ncl", "adrs/adr-002-daemon-for-caching-and-notification-barrier.ncl", "CHANGELOG.md", ], }, d.make_node { id = "reflection-modes", name = "Reflection Modes", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Operational procedures are first-class artifacts encoded as NCL DAG contracts. Modes declare actors, steps, dependencies, and error strategies — not prose.", artifact_paths = ["reflection/modes/", "reflection/schemas/", "crates/ontoref-reflection/"], }, d.make_node { id = "coder-process-memory", name = "Coder Process Memory", pole = 'Yin, level = 'Practice, description = "Session knowledge is captured as structured JSONL via coder record. Queryable, exportable, and promotable to reflection/knowledge/. The memory layer between sessions.", artifact_paths = ["reflection/modules/coder.nu", "reflection/schemas/coder.ncl"], }, d.make_node { id = "describe-query-layer", name = "Describe Query Layer", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "describe.nu aggregates all project sources and answers self-knowledge queries: what IS this, what can I DO, what can I NOT do, what tools exist, what is the impact of changing X.", artifact_paths = ["reflection/modules/describe.nu"], }, d.make_node { id = "ontoref-ontology-crate", name = "Ontoref Ontology Crate", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Rust implementation for loading and querying .ontology/ NCL files as typed structs. Provides the Core, Gate, and State types for ecosystem-level introspection.", artifact_paths = ["crates/ontoref-ontology/"], }, d.make_node { id = "ontoref-reflection-crate", name = "Ontoref Reflection Crate", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Rust implementation for loading, validating, and executing Reflection modes as NCL DAG contracts against project state.", artifact_paths = ["crates/ontoref-reflection/"], }, d.make_node { id = "adopt-ontoref-tooling", name = "Adopt Ontoref Tooling", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Migration system for onboarding existing projects into the ontoref protocol. Provides .ontology/ stub templates, .ontoref/config.ncl template, scripts/ontoref thin wrapper, and the adopt_ontoref mode+form+script that wire everything up idempotently.", artifact_paths = [ "ontoref", "templates/ontology/", "templates/ontoref-config.ncl", "templates/scripts-ontoref", "reflection/modes/adopt_ontoref.ncl", "reflection/forms/adopt_ontoref.ncl", "reflection/templates/adopt_ontoref.nu.j2", ], }, d.make_node { id = "web-presence", name = "Web Presence", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Landing page at assets/web/ describing the ontoref protocol to external audiences. Bilingual (EN/ES), covers protocol layers, yin/yang duality, crates, and adoption path. Self-description artifact.", artifact_paths = ["assets/web/src/index.html", "assets/web/index.html", "README.md", "assets/architecture.svg"], }, d.make_node { id = "ontoref-daemon", name = "Ontoref Daemon", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Runtime support daemon for the ontoref protocol. Provides NCL export caching, file watching, actor registry, notification barrier, HTTP API, MCP server (stdio + streamable-HTTP), Q&A NCL persistence, quick-actions catalog, and passive drift observation. Reads .ontoref/config.ncl at startup.", invariant = false, artifact_paths = [ "crates/ontoref-daemon/", "reflection/modules/services.nu", "crates/ontoref-daemon/src/ui/qa_ncl.rs", "crates/ontoref-daemon/src/ui/drift_watcher.rs", "crates/ontoref-daemon/src/mcp/mod.rs", ], }, d.make_node { id = "qa-knowledge-store", name = "Q&A Knowledge Store", pole = 'Yin, level = 'Practice, description = "Accumulated Q&A entries persisted as NCL — questions and answers captured during development sessions, AI interactions, and architectural reviews. Git-versioned, typed by QaEntry schema, queryable via MCP (ontoref_qa_list/add) and HTTP (/qa-json). Bridges session boundaries: knowledge is never lost between actor sessions.", artifact_paths = [ "reflection/qa.ncl", "reflection/schemas/qa.ncl", "crates/ontoref-daemon/src/ui/qa_ncl.rs", ], }, d.make_node { id = "quick-actions", name = "Quick Actions Catalog", pole = 'Yang, level = 'Practice, description = "Runnable shortcuts over existing reflection modes. Configured as quick_actions in .ontoref/config.ncl (id, label, icon, category, mode, actors). Accessible from UI (/actions), CLI (./ontoref), and MCP (ontoref_action_list/add). New modes created via ontoref_action_add are immediately available as actions. Reduces friction between knowing a mode exists and executing it.", artifact_paths = [ ".ontoref/config.ncl", "crates/ontoref-daemon/templates/pages/actions.html", "reflection/modes/", ], }, d.make_node { id = "drift-observation", name = "Passive Drift Observation", pole = 'Spiral, level = 'Practice, description = "Background observer that bridges Yang code artifacts with Yin ontology declarations. Watches crates/, .ontology/, adrs/, reflection/modes/ for changes; after a debounce window runs sync scan + sync diff; if MISSING/STALE/DRIFT/BROKEN items are found emits an ontology_drift notification. Never applies changes automatically — apply remains a deliberate human or agent act.", artifact_paths = [ "crates/ontoref-daemon/src/ui/drift_watcher.rs", "reflection/modes/sync-ontology.ncl", ], }, ], edges = [ { from = "self-describing", to = "dag-formalized", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "self-describing", to = "adr-lifecycle", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "self-describing", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "ontology-vs-reflection", to = "dag-formalized", kind = 'Resolves, weight = 'High }, { from = "ontology-vs-reflection", to = "coder-process-memory", kind = 'Resolves, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "dag-formalized", to = "ontoref-ontology-crate", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "reflection-modes", to = "ontoref-reflection-crate", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "no-enforcement", to = "formalization-vs-adoption", kind = 'Resolves, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "protocol-not-runtime", to = "no-enforcement", kind = 'Implies, weight = 'High }, { from = "adr-lifecycle", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "describe-query-layer", to = "dag-formalized", kind = 'DependsOn, weight = 'High }, { from = "coder-process-memory", to = "describe-query-layer", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "ontoref-daemon", to = "ontoref-ontology-crate", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'High }, { from = "ontoref-daemon", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "protocol-not-runtime", to = "ontoref-daemon", kind = 'Contradicts, weight = 'Low, note = "Daemon is optional runtime support, not a protocol requirement. Protocol functions without it." }, { from = "no-enforcement", to = "adopt-ontoref-tooling", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High, note = "Adoption is voluntary — the tooling makes it easy but never mandatory." }, { from = "adopt-ontoref-tooling", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'DependsOn, weight = 'High }, { from = "self-describing", to = "web-presence", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "web-presence", to = "adopt-ontoref-tooling", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'Medium }, # Q&A Knowledge Store edges { from = "qa-knowledge-store", to = "dag-formalized", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High, note = "Q&A entries are typed NCL records, git-versioned — knowledge as DAG." }, { from = "qa-knowledge-store", to = "coder-process-memory", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'High, note = "Q&A is the persistent layer; coder.nu is the session capture layer. Together they form the full memory stack." }, { from = "ontoref-daemon", to = "qa-knowledge-store", kind = 'Contains, weight = 'High }, # Quick Actions edges { from = "quick-actions", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'DependsOn, weight = 'High, note = "Each quick action invokes a reflection mode by id." }, { from = "quick-actions", to = "ontoref-daemon", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'Medium }, { from = "describe-query-layer", to = "quick-actions", kind = 'Complements, weight = 'Medium, note = "describe capabilities lists available modes; quick-actions makes them executable." }, # Drift Observation edges { from = "drift-observation", to = "ontoref-daemon", kind = 'ManifestsIn, weight = 'High }, { from = "drift-observation", to = "ontology-vs-reflection", kind = 'Resolves, weight = 'Medium, note = "Drift observer continuously monitors the gap between Yin (ontology) and Yang (code). Passive resolution — it signals drift without forcing resolution." }, { from = "drift-observation", to = "reflection-modes", kind = 'DependsOn, weight = 'High, note = "Invokes sync-ontology mode steps (scan, diff) as read-only sub-processes." }, ], }